Interior designers frequently encounter common pitfalls when homeowners choose tile: certain patterns, no matter how stylish in isolation, can overwhelm a room and detract from its overall aesthetic. Here’s a breakdown of the five most problematic choices, according to industry experts.
Small-Scale, High-Contrast Mosaics: A Visual Distraction
Small, high-contrast mosaic tiles are a frequent offender. Designers such as Peter Miles of The Drawing Board explain that these tiles “pull the eye in too many directions,” emphasizing grout lines instead of the room’s intended focal points. The effect is a busy, restless appearance that can disrupt visual flow. Beyond aesthetics, these patterns are also harder to keep clean.
Penny Tiles Everywhere: Overwhelming Bathrooms
Small-format penny tiles are popular in powder rooms, especially those with vintage decor. However, Molly Torres Portnof of DATE Interiors warns against using them on both walls and floors. The resulting visual density creates an overwhelming effect. The solution? Combine penny tiles with larger-format surfaces for balance.
Dramatic Veined Tiles: Chaos in Small Spaces
Heavily veined tiles can be striking, but they demand careful placement. Tracy Morris, founder of Tracy Morris Design, points out that these tiles become chaotic in small or already busy rooms. If a space already features bold colors or patterns, a heavily veined tile will amplify the clutter. These work best in large kitchens with minimal competing design elements.
Mixing Too Many Tile Types: A Lack of Cohesion
Resist the urge to combine too many different tile types within a single room. According to Winn, this leads to a disjointed, cluttered look. This is a common mistake in small spaces like bars or kitchens where backsplashes compete with flooring and countertops. The key is restraint: select one primary tile and use a complementary finish for cohesion.
The Importance of Intentional Design
“Creating a polished look means giving the eye a place to rest, not overwhelming it with too many competing patterns.” – Winn
Overuse of busy tiles is a sign of unfocused design. Thoughtful tile selection is about balance: using patterns strategically to enhance, not detract from, the overall space. Focus on simplicity and cohesion.
Choosing tile requires more than just picking a style; it demands an understanding of scale, contrast, and the existing design elements. Following these guidelines will help avoid common mistakes and ensure a more harmonious and visually appealing interior.
